J-Man’s 2017 Muskie Trolling Report: Lake of the Woods; Sabaskong Bay & Area

HAPPY NEW YEAR, muskie nuts!  The 2017 fall trolling season was interesting.  Read on to find out how…………….

Muskies Landed: 30
Days Fished: 9 full days, 2 half days

The bay at the resort was frozen hard the morning of November 9, causing an end to the season much too early.

Fish lost during the fight: 1

Fish that hooked up and fell right off: 19

We assume all fish that hit, but don’t hook-up and all fish that fall off during the fight are muskies because pike NEVER fall off!! 

Pike Landed: 23 (I don’t recall measuring one this past year.)

Total Strikes in 2017: 73

% of Muskies Landed vs Total Strikes: 30/73 = 41.1% (Down 7% from 2016.)
% of Muskies Landed minus Confirmed Pike: 30/50 = 60% (Down 17 % from 2016.)

Previous Years Totals

2016: 68 fish in 22 full days & 2 half days
2015: 69 fish in 20 days
2014: 90 fish in 22 days
2013: 87 fish in 20 days
2012: 53 fish in 20 days
2011: 48 fish in 16 full days & 6 half days
2010: 57 fish in 14 full days & 5 half days
2009: 71 fish in 22 days

Thoughts on Numbers
The target average of 3 muskies per day is pretty much dead on this year.  Strangely, the low overall number has me feeling both very frustrated and extremely proud at the same time.   The weather conditions dictated a lot of what we could do out there this fall, more so than any other year I can recall.  Though the total of 30 muskies landed is about the lowest I can remember going back to 2005 when I started trying to keep good records, only 2007 was lower in terms of fish caught and similar days on the water.    Despite what was, by far, the toughest sustained weather pattern I have ever had to fish in for an extended period, we found some fish simply by grinding it out every single day.

Size Distribution
Good overall average size again this year with over 2/3 of our landed fish over the 40” mark and 20% of them 45” and up.   The smaller fish were all in the 35”-40” range except one peanut that would not have made 30” and another that was closer to 35” than 30”.  Please see the usual disclosure below.

Sub 30”: 1
30” – < 35”: 1
35” – < 40”: 8
40” – < 45”: 14

45” – < 48”: 2 (45”, 46.5”)
48” – < 50”: 3 (48.5”, 49.25”, 49.5”)

50”+: 1 (51.75” Super Fatty)

In the interest of full disclosure, please note I am not measuring every fish anymore.  We will often dump them at boat side without netting or measuring in the interest of less time out of water or less time with our baits out of water when things are happening.  We feel like we have enough experience to gauge whether a fish is within a 5” range.  Anything that looks big enough to go 45” was put on the board for a quick verification of its size.  Some smaller fish were measured as well, but not each and every fish.

Percentage of Fish 45+

2017: 6 of 30 = 20%
2016: 15 of 68 = 22.06%
2015: 11 of 69 = 15.94%
2014: 17 of 90 = 18.9%
2013: 15 of 87 = 17.2%
2012: 8 of 53 = 15.1%
2011: 10 of 48 = 20.8%
2010: 13 of 57 = 22.8%
2009: 8 of 71 = 11.3%

Thoughts on Size
It took a while for us to get a fish over 45” during the fall troll, but once we did, 6 of the last 13 fish were 45” or bigger.  As well as one near miss that was a chunky 44.5” so similar to last year….we didn’t get numbers in tough conditions, but we got some quality fish.   The quality of fish helps take some of the sting out of losing time and numbers due to the early freeze.  For me personally, it feels like we really earned those nice fish by applying what we have learned in past years.

Lures

Supernatural Big Baits
10” Headlocks: 2
12” Headlocks: 4
12” Mattlocks: 1

10” Jake: 4
Franky: 4
9” Krave: 6
Wick Onez “Kingpinz”: 3
13” Grandma: 3
9” Grandma: 1
Blue Water Baits: 1
DK Fifty Finder Shallow: 1

Thoughts on Baits
Once again, Supernatural Big Baits showed why they are a go-to lure family in my boat.  A 12” HL landed the 2nd largest of the fall at 49.5”.  An old fave even got back in on the fun in 2017, but more on that later.

The Kingpinz lived up to it’s big fish reputation again as well, landing a 45” and 46.5” out of the 3 caught on them.

Paulie Rod Builder caught 4 on his Franky bait, including a 48.5”, but we know little about it.  In fact, we had no idea what kind of bait it was until he caught a fish on it.  Once it was proven to be a fish catcher, we looked for a marking on it to tell us what kind of bait it was.  I had never seen one prior and haven’t seen one since.  Paulie wasn’t much help because he has no idea where it came from either.  😊

paulie48half03nov2017cropped

The DK Fifty Finder Platinum Shallow landed the biggie.  This was a very cool thing because Dave asked me if I would be willing to beat up a bait that he worked hard to get the way he wanted it.  Of course, I was happy to oblige, and it turned out very well for lure maker and field tester both.  You will see the entire story on an episode of Video Monday coming soon so don’t miss it!

jman51-75muskie05nov2017cropped


Rod Position Related to Structure
Outside Rod: 15
Inside Rod: 10
Middle Rod: 5

A second consecutive trolling season with reduced middle rod activity.  Hmmmmmm.   Lack of bait perhaps?

Depth/Structure
Not much new here.  The lack of bait fish was frustrating, but we can seemingly blame that on the severe cold fronts that moved through.  This drastically dropped water temps more than 10 degrees in 10 days at the end of October.   Having surface temps go from 54 to 40 degrees in 10 days and then go under 36 degrees within the next 5 days totally blew up any bait fish staging and spawning pattern.   Multiple fish catches were almost zero in areas that have produced 3-4 fish at times when baitfish are present during staging and spawning.   This made the shoreline and structure related to shoreline (underwater tips, traditional points, etc) and reef structures even more important in our runs.   The usual 8-10 feet of water average put us in contact with that structure and produced fish despite a lack of baitfish during most of the fall trolling season.

Highlights
Some nice fish to end the season.   The 51.75” came on Sunday morning of the Epic and started a good 24 hour run of 7 fish from 40” to 51.75” that ended with a 49.25” and 49.5” landed less than an hour apart.

The return of Perchie!!!    After being semi-retired after his rookie season in 2013, and full retired since 2015…..I asked Brett to help me surprise Duff and had Perchie, my original 12” Headlock, sent down to SBB shop in St Paul to be refinished.  Perchie came back just the way I wanted.  He looked as beat up as ever, but was freshly sealed and ready to rock and roll one more time.  My plan was to give Perchie another run or two this past fall when conditions were prime and fish were active.   Well, conditions never came close to prime, but I called his number a couple of times anyway to see if he could still dance.    After landing a nice 43”, he was BAAAAAAAACK!    After studying my records, I count 14 muskies in 2013, and then 1 muskie in very limited water time in 2014 (semi-retirement.)   I don’t think he saw the water in 2015 and I know he stayed dry all of 2016.   His limited run in 2017 gave him a total of 16 muskies landed with an average** of 43.75”.   Only 2 of the 16 muskies were less than 40”  Of course, there have been multiple pike caught on Perchie as well, but I have never held that against him.

Using my records, Perchie has landed the following muskies: mid-to-high 30s, 39, 40, low 40s, low 40s, 42.5, 43, 43.5, 44, 44.5, 45.5, 46, 48.25, 48.5, 50, 50.25.

jman43perchie06nov2017.jpg
The 16th muskie to have lost a fight with Perchie was a 43″.

**Please note: for the sake of being conservative, when calculating the average size, I used 35” for the “mid-to-high 30s” and 40” for both of the “low 40s” fish that were not measured.

Above photos show Perchie before his new skin was put on.  I can’t wait to see what the future holds for Ole Perchie!!

We know we can find some fish in water temps under 35 degrees, if we must.  I prefer not to, but we shall take it 1 fall at a time.

Tom, Dave and I managed a 7 fish day on October 20 in the sunshine with water temps almost up to mid 50s.   There was nothing large in that bunch though.

The Epic did include a 5 fish day that started with the 51.75” and also included: 40ish, 45”, 44.5”, 40ish.

Not So Cool Stuff
WEATHER!  Yeah, it was horrible.   Extreme cold and high wind is a deadly combination.   I have fished in some less than ideal conditions in the past and generally go out of my way to avoid trolling in rollers.   A time or two this year, it was unavoidable.    I have owned the Pooh boat since spring of 2006 and never once have I taken a wave over the bow of the boat.   This year, we managed to get it twice.  The first occurred while trolling through some nasty rollers to get around a point and out of the wind we had been hiding from most of the morning but could not avoid in the area we were in.  This was only a partial rinse.   Later that day, we speared one completely on the way home.  With the freezing conditions, it was more than a little not good.   I do not care to ever do that again and will take more steps to avoid this in the future, even if it means losing part of a day on the water late in the season.

A tilt/trim motor problem cost us half the day to start the Epic.   With the usual slow start on Day 1 after the boys arrive, unload and load gear, etc…..the day is shorter to begin with.  Add the tilt/trim motor issue that led to an early ending, to a day that had wind, cold, white out blizzard conditions and more boat traffic than I can ever remember in November and you end up with the Pooh boat recording its first skunk in almost 3 seasons of trolling.   The two big pike we landed that day in the snowstorm were not any cause for celebration.  See how Cousin Jeff saved the Epic in the special thanks section.

IMG_20171104_2116207
In the shop with a tilt/trim motor problem after part of a day fishing in blizzard conditions.

Equipment/Gear
The new trolling rods from Venture Custom Rods were AWESOME.   We tweaked last year’s models slightly and were beyond pleased with the results.    Lamiglass blanks, aluminum reel seats with double nuts, spiral wrap, EVA foam handles and out of this world threadwork and customization from Paul Amberg.   This is the kind of thing you can get for the angler that has everything and they will be blown away.   The right equipment for the job always makes life easier and more enjoyable.

We had some trouble with GoPro batteries in the extreme cold conditions, but I can’t blame them for that.  Overall, the cameras held up pretty well and captured some great footage for Video Mondays again.

I am dying to get a couple of Helix 12 Megas, but trying to wait until a new rig.   There is nothing wrong with the job my current Birds are doing, despite them being older technology.

The Pooh boat is aging. He is going to need to be replaced sooner rather than later.   I may buy something used if I can find the right rig until we get a few more bigger projects done at the resort and free up some funds in the capital budget for a new Competitor 205 tiller with all the bells and whistles.  If anyone sees any well taken care of Alumacraft Tournament Pro 185 boats for sale out there, please do let me know!  They are not easy to find due to their vintage (2003 to 2005ish.)

Cabelas late season extreme guidewear, inferno boots and some base layering did the job on the cold.  I wouldn’t want to fish in that kind of weather every fall, but this gear makes it manageable.

Other Observations
The cold weather conditions, coupled with wind, snow, wind, sleet, wind, rain, wind, clouds, wind….did I mention wind, made it miserable to be out there when the fish weren’t co-operating.  Combing this with the aforementioned lack of baitfish may have led to…….

…….solunar table data being even more important than I can remember other years.   While we tried to focus on proven areas during these times, we had significantly more activity during moonrise, moonset and major activity periods when we could fish them during any given day.

Our first 9 fish were caught in 52-54 degree water on October 20 and 21.  Our last few fish were caught as low as 33.6 degrees on November 7.   A total of 8 fish were caught in water temps below 36 degrees on the surface.

Many more fish caught on back hooks this year.   Also a large number of fish that fell off or didn’t hook up considering our significantly number of days on the water.   Very few fish seemed to be crushing baits in kill and/or feeding mode.  Even the biggie of the season was hooked on the rear treble.   Fish seemed to be nipping short throughout the cold fronts, which caused hook-up percentage to be down significantly.  We had 1 day during Epic Pre-Fishing with 10 strikes that turned into 2 muskies, 6 pike and 2 that popped right off.   You can’t help but wonder how many following fish didn’t try to eat or missed baits completely and lost interest.   Even Paulie Rod Builder started catching them on the back hook in the Pooh boat this year, which is something he said he had never done before.

From 2016…….”as we get busier into late October, I expect to spend less time fishing and more time working as the season winds down.  I fished 4 and a half days in October 2016, but was able to make up for missing out with some extra November days.  When weather patterns return to normal, I foresee a fewer number of days trolling and a resulting drop in overall numbers.”

It looks as if I was a bit prophetic when I wrote this report last year.   October time on the water went down to 3 days in 2017, with only 2 of those being prior to guests checking out and docks coming out of the water.   Getting froze out early and losing almost half of the average number of days on the water was especially tough to swallow this year after a couple of extended November fishing seasons.

Special Thanks to:

To cousin Jeff Morrison for “taking a look” at a crapped-out tilt/trim motor and refusing to quit tinkering until it was removed, fiddled with and tested for operation.   Jeff saved the 2017 Epic and I could not be more thankful to have amazing friends and family that share their skills and talents when they are needed most.  

Some of the rest of these will be repeating year after year so humor me a bit……

Duffy Thury of Supernatural Big Baits ( www.supernaturalbigbaits.com ) for making baits that big fish cannot resist.  Also Brett Erickson at Supernatural Big Baits as well.  Check them out at a Muskie Expo near you this winter.

Paul Amberg of Venture Custom Rods ( www.venturecustomrods.com ) for the sweetest trolling rods and amazing attention to detail.  The new Team Epic set built on Lamiglass blanks are absolutely incredible tools.  Contact Paul to check his winter show schedule so you can put your eyes and hands on his art live and in person.

Dave Kormanyos (DK Musky Lures) for asking me to test drive a DK FF Platinum Shallow that landed what might have been the heaviest muskie I have ever caught.   Let me know if you want to get in touch with Dave about getting into his buying group on facebook.   He will do draws for the option to buy so baits can be distributed to as many anglers as possible when available.

Mike Blewett (Wick Onez Musky Customz) for the Kingpinz collection.  Great baits with some of the most amazing paint jobs you will find on a lure.

Lidio Azevedo (Blue Water Baits) for always responding to my questions about running depths with different sizes of lips when I’m running his awesome handmade lures.  Thanks, Lideo!

Dick Moore of Moore’s Lure ( www.mooreslures.com ) – For all my terminal tackle needs.

Bob Schmid of Just Encase tackle boxes ( www.justencase.com )  Simply the best in bait storage.

Chad Wyss for sending some baits for us to beat up during the Epic.   We look forward to having more days to get them dialed in next year.

To Tom and Dave for helping me shake off the rust with some October practice fishing.

To Paulie, Mitch, Dean and Brady for hanging in there through nasty weather and a couple of mechanical issues to make fishing in the worst conditions tolerable because of the good company.

Final Thoughts
This was easily the worst set of conditions we have faced since starting to fish hard in the fall.   Sustained sub-freezing temps with high winds are not something to be taken lightly.  I learned a lot about how this can affect your safety this past fall.  There is a lot more to it than you might think if you haven’t experienced it yourself.   The fish will be there another day.  Make sure you are safe to be there another day as well.   My upcoming seminar in Appleton, WI in March will feature some time spent on this subject.  It is as important as life and death.

I intend to lead by example and take no chances when one mistake or problem can lead to the end.

Safety first.  Always.

That is all.

J-Man

J-Man’s 2016 Muskie Trolling Report: Lake of the Woods; Sabaskong Bay & Area

HAPPY NEW YEAR!!! 

If you still care about the 2016 trolling season in the Pooh Boat, here is the better late than never summary of action and adventure.

Muskies Landed: 68
Days Fished: 22 full days, 2 half days

Fish lost during the fight & fish that hooked up and fell right off: 13

Fish that didn’t hook up: 9

We assume all fish that hit, but don’t hook-up and all fish that fall off during the fight are muskies because pike NEVER fall off!! 

Pike Landed: 51 (2 less than 2015.  Largest measured: 41”, 40”, 40”)

Total Strikes 2016: 141 (down 8 from 2015)

% of Muskies Landed of Total Strikes: 68/141 = 48.2% (up 2% from 2015)
% of Muskies Landed minus Confirmed Pike: 68/90 = 75.9% (up 3.7% from 2015)

Previous Years Totals

2015: 69 fish in 20 days
2014: 90 fish in 22 days
2013: 87 fish in 20 days
2012: 53 fish in 20 days
2011: 48 fish in 16 full days & 6 half days
2010: 57 fish in 14 full days & 5 half days
2009: 71 fish in 22 days

Thoughts on Numbers
We missed our target average of 3 fish per day by 1 fish, so of course it feels a little disappointing.   However, based on the conditions we faced during our time on the water, I feel like we did well all things considered.  Having half of the fish that hooked up and fell off pretty quick might have made for a very different feel to the total numbers.

Size Distribution
The muskies and pike fisheries on Lake of the Woods continue to trend healthy.   Average size and thickness of fall fish have been excellent and that was the case again this past fall.   Catching 4+ footers with girth is, of course, what we dream about.  However, when you get a couple of 44s, a 45 and a 46 that are super slobs, you can’t help but be in awe of what this lake is capable of producing.
Sub 30”: 1
30” – < 35”: 6
35” – < 40”: 19
40” – < 45”: 27

45” – < 48”: 11 (45”, 45”, 45”, 45.5”, 46”, 46”, 46.5”, 46.75”, 47.5”, 47.5”, 47.5”)
48” – < 50”: 2 (48”, 48.5”)

50”+: 2 (50”, 50.5”)

In the interest of full disclosure, please note I am not measuring each and every fish anymore.  We will often dump them at boatside without netting or measuring in the interest of less time out of water or less time with our baits out of water when things are happening.  We feel like we have enough experience to gauge whether a fish is within a 5” range.  Anything that looks big enough to go 45” was put on the board for a quick verification of its size.  Some smaller fish were measured as well, but not each and every fish.

Percentage of Fish 45+

2016: 15 of 68 = 22.06%
2015: 11 of 69 = 15.94%
2014: 17 of 90 = 18.9%
2013: 15 of 87 = 17.2%
2012: 8 of 53 = 15.1%
2011: 10 of 48 = 20.8%
2010: 13 of 57 = 22.8%
2009: 8 of 71 = 11.3%

Thoughts on Size
Despite a couple less fish in the 48” and above category, the numbers of 45” and bigger were up significantly from last year.  Especially during the Epic, which saw only 23 fish for the week, but 10 of them were 45” and larger.  This gave us a 43.5% rate.  When almost half of the fish you catch are 45” or above, you can say you had a good week even when you don’t hit your numbers target.

Lures/Colours

9.5” Kraves: 17
10” Jakes: 16
13” Grandmas: 8
Slammers: 3
9” Grandmas: 2
Myers: 1

Supernatural Big Baits

10” Headlocks: 7
12” Headlocks: 3
Mattlocks: 2

Wick Onez “Kingpinz”: 6
Blue Water Baits: 2 (12” Herring, 9” Cisco)
DK Fifty Finder: 1

Thoughts on Baits
Smaller baits seemed to be the meal of choice again, despite offering them bigger stuff on a regular basis.  This pattern seems to hold true whenever there isn’t a lot of bait fish spawning in process.

Supernaturals landed the biggest share of fish over 45” again so that is definitely a pattern now with 3 years in a row having similar results.  Again, we used a variety of colours and only 1 of them that I can remember did not get bit.   The action of this bait just seems to get better the more I beat them up.  Especially, some of the baits I have had for multiple seasons.   The only one I have had to retire is the original Perchy.  The others are all going strong with fresh hooks and occasional lip pin replacements.

The Kinpinz from Wick Ones came through late with the biggest fish of the year and had its share of nice fish as well.   The big Grandma proved it will always have a place in the line-up with a strong showing for the big bait family.   I am still looking forward to more Bluewater Baits in the boat and giving them a chance when baitfish are up and bring in the basin fish.

Jakes and Kraves were reliable and steady.   These 2 baits just seem to work. Period.

Colour patterns didn’t really stand out over the course of the 20+ day trolling season in the Pooh boat.   One thing that did seem to shine was holographic type patterns.   The flash these types of patterns give off was the ticket, especially on days with bright sunshine and improved water clarity.   Contrasting colours had good results as well as natural colours, but the flash of reflective tape or holographic patterns definitely led the way.

Rod Position Related to Structure
Outside Rod: 34
Inside Rod: 27
Middle Rod: 7

This is the lowest number for middle rod fish I can remember.   There were a few more days of 2 rods only, but even when 3 rods were running, the middle rod seemed stone cold.   There was only a couple 45”+ fish that hit the middle rod despite mixing up the bait offerings and line lengths from start to finish.

Depth/Structure
Nothing much new here as far as results go.   With a lack of bait on a regular basis, we spent more time on deeper runs than normal, but it did not produce anything significant in terms of results.   The majority of our big fish came from typical fall patterns and depths.   I am not one to force feed something over and over when it is not working.  Trying something new when the fish aren’t co-operating ensures we aren’t missing them if they are close by, but not in our normal patterns.   We did land a few more fish on large reef complexes after working a few of them harder than in the past.   I expect to do more of this in future fall seasons and suggest you do as well.

Highlights

BEST EPIC EVER.   Many of you will know that the week that Dean and Brady join me has become known as “The Epic.”   Now if you aren’t aware of the events in the several months leading up to the fall, you will wonder how the lowest number of fish caught in an Epic trip can be the best.  When news came of Deano having a heart attack, and then a second one that resulted in a fall and traumatic brain injury, the Epic was in severe danger of never being the same again.    Brady and I spoke more than once in the following weeks after about what we should do in case Deano would not be able to join us.   However, in true Deano fashion, he came through better than anyone could ever have hoped for and was back to work even before the Epic began.   The amount of rehab and hard work he had to put in to get his life back to normal would have broken many of us.   For me, the entire week was made the moment he arrived with Brady and all members of Team Epic were present.  The fact that Dean put on a clinic was an incredible bonus.   The results were not pretty for Brady and I, but I know I can speak for both of us when I say we couldn’t have been more thrilled to get our asses handed to us.  When Deano put 3 on the board on Day 1, including a 50″, Brady & I knew we were in trouble.

Not So Cool Stuff

PARKING IT!  I managed to park Pooh on some rocks a couple times last fall.  The first park job was easily the worst position I had ever been in on the water.   Some wind was blowing in and pushed us in and on to a boulder point while releasing a pain-in-the-butt pike.   With a heck of a lot of pushing with paddles, Mitch and I managed to get over and off the edge of the point, but it wasn’t looking good.

new-movie-2-movie_snapshot

The second park job was the following week and made the first look like a walk in the park in comparison.  With an even stronger wind, I was following the Lakemaster contour lines and realized I was in trouble on a reef I hadn’t fished in a long time.   I had it properly marked on my old Lowrance units, but was not able to find my X-25 so I did not have in in the boat.   This reef was very poorly marked and we ended up beached on the center keel with waves crashing over the back of the boat and filling Pooh up with water.  The angle the boat was sitting did not allow water to get pumped out by the bilge so with added weight from water and a full 40 gallons of gas, pushing with paddles was not going well.    It got to the point that we gave up and I made the call for someone to come up and try to pull us off the reef.   Luckily, it was a warm day and we were not that far from home yet.   Eventually, the wind moved us very slightly and the bilge kicked on to get rid of some weight.   I could see a trail of white/silver paint from the keel on the rock which indicated we were moving a little bit at a time.   Eventually we did get off the other end of this big, mostly flat rock, but we were parked for well over an hour.   After clearing the reef, we headed for the boat ramp to check for damage to Pooh, but he seemed to come through the ordeal quite well.  UGH.  NOT GOOD.  VERY NOT GOOD.  The Captain screwed up big time on that one.   Just glad it didn’t ruin the day or the trip.

new-movie-3-movie_snapshot

LOOK MA, NO HANDLE!!    Bushings, washers, spacers, yadda, yadda, yadda.  Tiller handle on Pooh gets sloppy on occasion and I tighten it up as needed.  On Day 1 of the Epic, it was feeling quite loose, so I gave it a tighten and the bolt holding it together broke.   Leaving the first spot, the handle literally detached from the engine.  Hmmmmmmmm.   The bolt holding a rail mount Down-East rod holder was the jerry-rigged solution that got us through the day.   That night, we backed Pooh over to the new shop and found enough stuff in the miscellaneous nuts and bolts bin to make it work.  That got us through the week and through another week of the Bonus Round.   I had a similar issue in the past and it ended up costing about $800 bucks in parts to get it fixed.   Looks like it will be about the same to repair it properly for next season.  I may buy double the bushings so they can be replaced before it causes the entire handle set-up to get ruined.

WEATHER!  Yes, once again the weather was too warm for ideal conditions.  Temps were in the 70s for the start of the Epic.  Action was heating up the last week of October as the temps went down steadily, but seemed to stall out when the sun came out and kept things well above normal during daytime and overnight.   When will we have a normal fall weather pattern again?  We can only hope for soon!

WIND!! It was very windy more days than not.  The wind direction often pinned us to particular areas of the lake for multiple days in a row.  I detest fishing in the wind for reasons above (potential park jobs) and still have not seen enough evidence that fishing in high winds and big rollers makes more sense than trying to avoid it when possible.

LOSING BAITS!   Lost a Headlock and Kingpinz this year.  I’m still a little depressed.   As Forrest Gump would say, “That’s all I have to say……about that.”

Equipment/Gear

VENTURE CUSTOM RODS!!  Three rods from Paul Amberg made just for trolling turned out awesome.   With upgrades to the reel seats and EVA foam handles, they stand out amongst their peers.  The thread art and guide wrap options are endless to make these one of a kind units.  Action and handling was excellent and all those using the rods loved them.  I will add a couple more of these to the line-up next year and will be set up with a full arsenal of Venture Custom Rods.

Upgraded the net cam GoPro to a Hero 3+ to allow for higher resolution action on the fish coming into the net.   A 3-camera line-up with full 1080p/60 fps should make for some crystal clear HD Video Mondays starting January 9, 2017 so be sure to follow the youtube channel or facebook page for announcements and links to new videos.

Other Observations
As we get busier into late October, I expect to spend less time fishing and more time working as the season winds down.  I fished 4 and a half days in October 2016, but was able to make up for missing out with some extra November days.  When weather patterns return to normal, I foresee a fewer number of days trolling and a resulting drop in overall numbers.  Hopefully, this is not the case, but I always say the best way to catch a lot of fish is to have as many baits in the water as possible for as many hours as possible.

Pumping rods didn’t seem to make nearly as much difference as it has in the past.   More data needed.  Is it November yet?

Special Thanks to:
Some of these will be repeating year after year so humor me a bit……

Duffy Thury (Supernatural Big Baits) for making baits that big fish cannot resist.

45headlocknetcam

Paul Amberg (Venture Custom Rods) for the sweet trolling rods.  Contact Paul to check his winter show schedule so you can check out his art live and in person.

Mike Blewett (Wick Onez Musky Customz) for the Kingpinz collection.  Great baits with some of the most amazing paint jobs you will find on a lure.

24-2jman50half17nov2016cropped50.5″ – Kingpinz

Dick Moore (Moore’s Lures) – For all my terminal tackle needs.

Bob Schmidt: (Just Encase tackle boxes).  Simply the best in tackle storage.

Lidio Azevedo (Blue Water Baits) for adding a few more BWBs to my collection.   Thanks, Lideo!

To Don, Linda, Tom, Dave, Eric, Brad, Mitch, Dean, Brady, Paul, and Jeff for some great times in the Pooh boat.  Also, special thanks to Collette and Lauren Roll for sharing their Husband & Dad with Brady and I again after a scary spring and summer.

season-end-2016The end of the 2016 trolling season in the Pooh boat.

Final Thoughts
It is easy to get frustrated and upset when things don’t go your way on the water.   Never lose sight of why we do what we do.   Catching fish is certainly the goal, but until we all learn that spending time on the water, whether it is alone or with people you care about, is more valuable than any caught or lost fish, then we will never know how blessed we are.  I’m beyond lucky that everyone that spent time in my boat this past fall feels the same way that I do.   If I had to do this for money, that might not be the case.

I will miss the Minnesota Muskie Expo this year because I was not aware that it has been moved to early March.   Hopefully I can figure out a way to fit it back into my off-season schedule in the future, but in the meantime, I will be at the NW Sports Show in downtown Minneapolis for 1 or 2 days the weekend of March 25 so give me a shout if you want to get together and talk fishing.

50release

Cheers

J-Man

J-Man’s 2015 Muskie Trolling Report: Lake of the Woods; Sabaskong Bay & Area

Here we goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!

Muskies Landed: 69
Days Fished: 20

Muskies Lost During Fight: 6 (Down from last year’s 10.)
Fish That Hit and Fell Off Right Away or Didn’t Hook Up: 21

We assume all fish that hit, but don’t hook-up and all fish that fall off during the fight are muskies because pike NEVER fall off!!

Pike Landed: 53 (5 more than 2014. Only measured a few: 41”, 40”, 39”)

Total Strikes: 149 confirmed (175 in 2014)
% of Muskies Landed of Total Strikes: 69/149 = 46.3%
% of Muskies Landed minus Confirmed Pike: 69/96 = 71.9% (slightly higher than 2014)

Miles Travelled & Trolled Based on GPS: 1346 (67.3 miles per day)
Fuel Burned: 1207.95 Litres (319.5 gallons)

Previous Years Totals

2014: 90 fish in 22 days
2013: 87 fish in 20 days
2012: 53 fish in 20 days
2011: 48 fish in 16 full days & 6 half days
2010: 57 fish in 14 full days & 5 half days
2009: 71 fish in 22 days

Thoughts on Numbers
It is hard to imagine being unsatisfied with the above numbers, but after hitting 87 and 90 the previous 2 seasons, it feels like we left a lot out there this year.   Overall, nearly 3.5 fish per day on average is nothing to be ashamed of certainly, but the fact that the temps were warm and conditions were good late into the season makes it seems like we failed in some ways. More on that later.

Size Distribution
Again, the fishery is showing to be very healthy. We didn’t lose anything we thought was huge, save for one strike for Mitch that had some massive headshakes but fell right off. Fish again were thick and often felt bigger than they ended up being when they got to the boat.

Sub 30”: 0
30” – < 35”: 9
35” – < 40”: 22
40” – < 45”: 27
45” – < 48”: 6 (45”, 45”, 45.5”, 45.5”, 46”, 47”)
48” – < 50”: 2 (48”, 48.75”)
50”+: 3 (50”, 50.5”, 52.25”)

In the interest of full disclosure, please note I am not measuring each and every fish anymore. We will often dump them at boatside without netting or measuring in the interest of less time out of water or less time with our baits out of water when things are happening. We feel like we have enough experience to gauge whether a fish is within a 5” range. Anything that looks big enough to go 45” was put on the board for a quick verification of its size. Some smaller fish were measured as well, but not each and every fish.

Percentage of Fish 45+
2015: 11 of 69 = 15.94%
2014: 17 of 90 = 18.9%
2013: 15 of 87 = 17.2%
2012: 8 of 53 = 15.1%
2011: 10 of 48 = 20.8%
2010: 13 of 57 = 22.8%
2009: 8 of 71 = 11.3%

Thoughts on Size
Would have expected 1 or 2 more over 45” for the totals, but not surprised considering how things played out towards to end of my season on the water. We would always like more fish and certainly more 50’s in the bag, but have to be content overall. The big fish were VERY big this year.   Bruisers that all make you shake your head in awe.

Lures/Colours
10” Jakes: 24
9.5” Kraves: 9
9” Grandmas: 7
13” Grandmas:1

Supernatural Big Baits
12” Headlocks: 4
10” Headlocks: 9
Protoype model from Supernatural: 3

Wick Onez “Kingpinz”: 9
Blue Water Baits: 2 (Cisco)
DK Fifty Finder: 1

Thoughts on Baits
Fish seemed to want smaller baits for the first couple of weeks, but there was some bigger baits catching fish in other boats.  The numbers on Jakes, Grandmas and Kraves were up early before the bigger baits started to produce better later. I can’t really explain this other than saying the fish want what they want when they want it.  Here are how the biggies played out:

12” Headlocks – 45”
10” Headlocks – 50.5”, 48.75”, 45.5”, 45.5”
Krave – 50”, 45”
Wick Onez Kingpinz – 52.25”, 48”, 47”
Blue Water Baits Cisco – 46”

My theory on colour not being overly important when it comes to Supernatural Big Baits seemed to prove out this year. We had a pile of new baits in different colours to try and our goal was to get them all bit. We came awfully close to doing just that and even stuck a nice 42” on the “Woody” pattern 12” Headlock. This was a bait with no paint whatsoever. All it has is the clear coat and it got chomped not long after we put it in the water this year. The action of these baits it the key and though there seems to be a lot of imitators out there, there is one Supernatural! With almost half of the big fish coming on Supernatural big Baits, if you don’t have a few of these in your trolling line-up, you are doing yourself a disservice.

jman50-5-06nov2015
50.5″ – 10″ Headlock

 

 

Black/silver was a hot pattern this fall. After a couple of fish on that colour for a buddy’s boat, we went on a heck of a run with the sliver shiner pattern. The jailbird colour was productive again in different bait styles. Tennessee Shad and superman were also both reliable again. Wick Onez

Kingpinz were productive again this year. With more colours to play with, the fish ate several offerings. The KP also showed big fish will chomp them with the 47, 48 and 52.25 on the board.

mitch52-25-release.JPG
52.25″ = Kingpinz

The Jake is still a reliable bait. There was a stretch of 2 days that produced 18 fish and only 1 of them was on a larger profile bait. The 10” jake landed 16 of those fish, but none of those fish were bigger than low 40s. The

Krave was steady from start to finish.   The jailbird pattern was hot again; landing the first ever 50” on a Krave in the Pooh boat.

jman50release2crop
50″ – Krave

 

 

Blue Water Baits looked incredible in the water and held up to the beating nicely. With the fish a little less apt to go after larger profiles baits, it didn’t surprise me to see the 9” Cisco be the one to bag a couple of real nice fish. I fully expect the 9” and 12” Herrings to get chomped when conditions are right, but that just didn’t present itself this year. All these baits held up to the beatings on the rocks well and I would not hesitate to throw them in the water again in the future.

jman46-bwb-24oct2015.JPG
46″ – Blue Water baits 9″ Cisco

Another cool new bait for me was the Fifty Finder from DK Lures.   Managed a nice 41” on one of them and liked the action for a little something different. I beat these up pretty good as well and they took it all in stride. The aluminum lipped model as the one I used and I would go that way over the lexan again.

IMG_8700.JPG
41″ – DK Fifty Finder

 

 

Lastly, the Undertow from True Glide had incredible action and also held up well to some rock crushing. I believe this bait suffered the most from the fish not eating larger profile baits as much this past fall. I am looking forward to next October and November when fish act normal again to see what this bait can do.   Awesome bait from Joe Peterson.

Rod Position Related to Structure
Outside Rod: 27
Inside Rod: 21
Middle Rod: 21

One of the more even splits I can remember. Middle rod may have had higher numbers if there had been a 3rd line in the water during the 2 day stretch with 18 fish with just 2 rods going.  The biggies played out like this:

Inside: 1 (47”)
Middle: 6 (50.5”, 50”, 48.75”, 46”, 45.5”, 45”)
Outside: 4 (52.25”, 48”, 45.5”, 45”)

Depth/Structure
Pretty much the status quo again for me. We spent most of our time focused on the 10 foot range to allow us to hit tips and underwater points in shallow depths as we cruised along.   Saddles were much less productive this year, but this seems completely related to lack of baitfish in areas that have been full of bait in the past.   A crew that got gas from us moved out a bit deeper and had some great success, so that is something I will have to think about the in the future. I made passes in 12 and 15 feet, which is easy to do with the Humminbird depth highlighting option, but did not notice any more action for my boat. When there isn’t bait or fish biting in 10 feet, there is no harm in moving out a little deeper, but it just didn’t bring any more fish into the Pooh boat for us this year.

Highlights
Lots of highlights again this year. Three days come to mind for good reasons. A 3 fish day with Eric and Brad that yielded a 42”, 50 and 48.75” was a lot of fun. We may have had a few more, but we had our explore mode on and covered over 80 miles on the water that day trying out of the way places hoping to stumble into a pot of gold.   The fish all came from usual, reliable areas. Go figure.

Two days with Mitch that produced 18 fish (10 and 8.) Mitch handed me a whipping of epic proportions to the tune of 15-3. The final fish of that 2 day trip was a 52.25” personal best for Mitch. After netting his first “50” last fall, it was a huge thrill to push that up from 51.75”.

A 5 fish day with Deano and Brady that produced (in order): 45”, 47”, 48”, low 40s (not measured) and 50.5” might have been the best day overall for 2015. Multiple personal bests and best single days for my fishing partners: Lee O (42.5, 45), Mitch (52.25, 8 fish in one day), Todd and Amy with pb northerns were fun to be part of as well, Season best for J-Man.

No skunks again!  Well sorta!  On the 1st outing of the year, we managed to get skunked during our day of practice and getting kinks out of new gear.  But when we got serious, we managed to land at least 1 muskie each day on the water.

Not So Cool Stuff
With a series of unfortunate events coming together at the same time, Pooh was disabled a long way from home.   The short version is a cable from my bow mounted transducer bracket managed to get itself in a position to trip the tilt/trim switch at the bow of the boat that controls the big motor caused the 90 HP motor to start coming up and kept coming. Not realizing what was going on, the engine ended up stuck on the rear deck of the boat with the gear shifter broken off. I was distraught at the thought of Pooh’s season being over and figuring out a way to salvage the last few days of the trip with Dean and Brady. Luckily for us, Dean was back home for 1 day to watch high school volleyball and was able to bring up a back-up boat so that part of the problem was solved. On the ride in, I realized the cable cause this problem so felt a little better about the fact that it was a freak deal and wouldn’t happen again so once Pooh got fixed, life would be back to normal. In 2016.   After a long 3 hour ride in on the 9.9 HP kicker, we loaded the boat and were able to get cousin Dougie to take a look. A couple hours later, Pooh had a bionic gear shifter as a result of Dougie’s manufacturing skills and we were back on the water.

Rain! Lost track of how many all-day rains we had, but it was 4-5.   Fishing in the rain is no fun, but when the fish bite, it is tolerable. Rain really puts a damper on filming and photos, so many of the great fish caught from those days will not be seen on Video Mondays. BUMMER!!   Warm weather! Yes, this was not cool. The bait fish did not come in before I had to pull the pin on the season. Water temps were going to be prime after we packed up and left the resort. What a crazy weather year after 3-4 falls in a row where the temps were low enough that getting into November at all was dicey.

Equipment/Gear
Upgraded GoPros should make for sharper images on Video Mondays in the new year. I purchased Hero 3+ to upgrade from my original Hero 960s.   With an extended battery from Wasabi, I was able to go through a full day of constant filming on the bow camera with only 1 battery change. I’d highly recommend this option if you like to keep your cameras rolling.   The 20 minute loop option was great for keeping things organized on the bow camera as well. When you keep the date/time set properly, you can go back through your day much easier and pull the footage out (in 5 min segments) that you want to keep/use.

Cool new rod from Venture Custom Rods that I look forward to tweaking a little and landing some giants on next fall. Thanks to Paul Amberg for letting me play with one this fall.

Other Observations
The biggest observation for me was lack of baitfish, which I am blaming on warm weather.   Hopefully, weather will get back to normal for the time of year and we can see if this is going to be an ongoing thing or a weather related blip on the radar.   When the sun came out and water temps held or came up in November, action seemed to die off, especially in the mornings. Several days we could not get bit until after noon. After great morning action in the previous 2 falls, this was a frustrating change.   Baitfish was deep in places we’ve seen it in the past, but it never moved into the 10 and 15 foot of water that we need it to be at to make fish more catchable. This has to be weather/water temp related. Water temps never got down to the point where this bait came in to spawn. Baitfish was loaded in the 20 to 30 feet of water range throughout the fall.   We got more fish on points and tips and structural elements of that nature than over saddles and in channel, current, etc.

Special Thanks to: Some of these will be repeating year after year so humor me a bit……

Duffy Thury (Supernatural Big Baits) for another good supply of baits to beat up. The fish love them and so do I. I wouldn’t want to troll without several of these in the tackle box.

Mike Blewett (Wick Onez Musky Customz) for the Kingpinz collection. Great baits with some of the most amazing paint jobs you will find on a lure. Dick Moore (Moore’s Lure) – For all my terminal tackle needs.

Bob Schmidt: Just Encase tackle boxes. Simply the best in tackle storage. Thorne Bros Custom Rod & Tackle: Proud to be a Thorne Bros Pro Staffer. Nearly all of my gear is available through Thorne!

Lidio Azevedo (Blue Water Baits) for the opportunity to run some awesome Canadian made lures.   Thanks, Lidio!

Dave Kormanyos (DK Musky Lures) for the Fifty Finders! Very cool baits. Thanks to Andrew Rideout and Zac Buwalda for the hook-up.

To the Rabbi, Todd, Amy, Tom, Lee, Brad, Eric, Mitch, Dean, Brady, Brian, & Jeremy for taking time away from work, family and home to spend time in the Pooh boat with me this past fall.

Final Thoughts

After not being as excited to fish last fall as I normally would have been, I was looking forward to trolling even more-so than another other fall this year. I did not make it out casting during the 2015 season. Not one single time. Not having enough or experienced help at the resort was the main reason, but a sinus issue sucking my energy made me choose not to fish at night after the end of the day.   Getting out in the boat and doing some trolling is like my reward for making it through a long, busy season at the resort and spending it with cool friends is the best part.   Catching fish is a bonus.

I have a surgery date to correct my sinus issues and hope to put that behind me in late January so I will be home in Manitoba from mid-January to mid-February to take care of that, but otherwise plan to enjoy time away from the resort until spring. It will be nice to breathe like a normal human again after a couple of years fighting with my nose not working properly.

Thanks for following along with our adventures in the Pooh Boat again. Hopefully we will have more to report this time next year!

Cheers

J-Man

J-Man’s 2014 Fall Muskie Trolling Report: Lake of the Woods; Sabaskong Bay & Area

A little earlier than last year, but still a little later than I would have liked to get it out….here is the 2014 Fall Trolling Report……..

Muskies Landed: 90
Days Fished: 22

Muskies Lost During Fight: 10 (OUCH!! The most lost fish ever by far, including 3 on the last day of fishing.)
Fish That Hit and Fell Off Right Away or Didn’t Hook Up: 27

We assume all fish that hit, but don’t hook-up and all fish that fall off during the fight are muskies because pike NEVER fall off!!

Pike Landed: 48 (Only measured a couple pike, one of which was a very slobbery 38” that we thought was way bigger due to its massive gut.)

Total Strikes: 175 confirmed
% of Muskies Landed of Total Strikes: 90/175 = 51.4%
% of Muskies Landed minus Confirmed Pike: 90/127 = 70.9%

Previous Years Totals
2013: 87 fish in 20 days
2012: 53 fish in 20 days
2011: 48 fish in 16 full days & 6 half days
2010: 57 fish in 14 full days & 5 half days
2009: 71 fish in 22 days

Thoughts on Numbers
Last fall, I said I was blown away by the 87 fish total. This year, I can only think about what we left out there. A few fish that felt really heavy. We didn’t get to see any of the 10 fish that we dumped.   All those rips and several that were hooked up for a few seconds and then gone kind of haunt you at the end of the year. However, proper perspective comes into focus quickly and I cannot be anything less than thrilled with the results. The sweet part of the 9-0 is that the total was 89 based on my quick scribbling after each set of days. After going back through the video, I “found” one that was forgotten to get to 90 for the fall. We thought we had left fish #90 out there 3 times that last day with fish that were half way to the boat and then just fell off.

Size Distribution Another great distribution among size classes. A few less smaller ones this year and several of those in the 38-39 range appear to be moving up into the low 40s. The 40-45” class had a significant increase in numbers this year.

Sub 30”: 4
30” – < 35”: 6
35” – < 40”: 15
40” – < 45”: 48
45” – < 48”: 7 (45”, 45”, 46”, 46”, 46”, 47”, 47.5”)

48” – < 50”: 4 (48.25”, 48.5”, 48.5”, 49.5”)

50”+: 6 (50-1/8”, 51”, 51-3/8”, 51.5”, 51.75”, 52”)

In the interest of full disclosure, please note I am not measuring each and every fish anymore. We will often dump them at boatside without netting or measuring in the interest of less time out of water or less time with our baits out of water when things are happening. We feel like we have enough experience to gauge whether a fish is within a 5” range. Anything that looks big enough to go 45” was put on the board for a quick verification of its size. Some smaller fish were measured as well, but not each and every fish.

Percentage of Fish 45+
2014: 17 of 90 = 18.9%
2013: 15 of 87 = 17.2%
2012: 8 of 53 = 15.1%
2011: 10 of 48 = 20.8%
2010: 13 of 57 = 22.8%
2009: 8 of 71 = 11.3%

Thoughts on Size
EPIC! AGAIN! So many tankers and min-tankers to go with the super-tankers again this year. Of the “Fiddies”, only the 50-1/8” was not super-tank class. While none of the beasts this year were super slobs, they were solid, thick brutes that often fooled me on length. Partly due to having a different (bigger, deeper) net, but also the girth holding all the way through to the tails made them a bit tough to judge. The 52” that I landed had a head that had both Deano and I thinking bigger numbers because it was a head similar to his 54” from two years prior. It is ridiculous to say you are disappointed to see a fish hit 52”, but we sure thought that one was going go bigger. I thought maybe I had a new personal best over my 53” from the previous year. It was not to be, but perhaps that was fitting considering the way I darn near caused that fish to end up unmeasured with an ill-timed pull towards the net while it was lassoed. The title of that Video Monday episode will be “EPIC SAVE”. Thanks, Brady!! EPIC!! Lures/Colours
10” Jakes: 29
9.5” Kraves: 12
13” Grandmas: 5
Custom X: 4
9” Grandmas: 2
Giant Flatstick: 2
14” Jakes: 1
Jointed Deep Slammer: 1
Live Target: 1

12” Headlocks: 8
10” Headlocks: 14
Matlock: 1

Wick Onez “Kingpinz”: 10 (2 baits)

Thoughts on Baits
I got to play with even more new/different baits this year and found a couple more that will be mainstays in the tackle box. Big fish sure like Supernatural Big Baits!!!   Out of the 10 from 48.25” to 52”, 7 of them fell to the erratic wobble of a Headlock or Matlock. The biggies and their bait selection broke down this way:

12” Headlocks – 51.75”, 48.25”
10” Headlocks – 51.5”, 51-3/8”, 51”, 48.5”
Matlock – 48.5” 10”
Jake – 52”
Wick Onez Kingpinz – 50-1/8”, 49.5” (these fish were caught consecutively, with the 49.5” first and the 50-1/8” about 30 mins later.)

With the large number of Supernaturals on board this year, we only doubled up on big fish with 1 bait (48.5”, 51”), but that only feeds my theory that colour matters a little less with that bait because of its incredible action. Both big fish on the Kingpinz were on the Walleye pattern. Blonde Bombshell was the snack of choice for the biggest fish (52”) we landed this fall. Headlocks proved their worth again this year. I cannot say enough about the way they walk/wobble. It is so unlike any other bait we run. The length of the bait doesn’t seem to matter one bit. The fish love them both and I wouldn’t want to troll without some Headlocks at the ready. I’m excited to get more colours to try and keep seeing if theory can be proven wrong. Though it is tougher now with so many to choose from because if one goes an hour without getting bit, we often give it the quick hook and throw another one down there.

Some Headlocks after their beatings
Some Headlocks after their beatings

The promising rookie in the Pooh Boat is the Wick Onez “Kingpinz”. Seeing the paint job on these baits when they arrived made me feel instantly guilty about the beating I was going to put on them, but they held up well and proved to be a solid choice. Both of these baits got bit within 15 mins of being in the water. Neither of them landed a muskie below 40”. Only a small pike made their record less than perfect when it came to landing the right flavour of fish.   Out of the 10 fish landed on the 2 baits, the sizes were: (42.5”, 45”, 40”, 49.5”, 50-1/8”, 46”, 43”, 42.5”, 44”, 44”). These baits are built tough and are very easy to pop off snags when you get them hung up. I’m looking forward to a smorgasboard of incredible custom colour choices for the fall of 2015!

The Wally and Perchie Kingpinz before
The Wally and Perchie Kingpinz before

The 10” Jake did its thing again this past fall. Nothing overly dramatic besides the season biggest 52”. It just quietly kept producing fish, as it always does. Multiple patterns did well. Including: Blonde Bombshell aka Blondie, Black & Gold Metallic aka Goldielocks, and Superman (both Holoform and original.)

The early morning 52" -  10" Jake
The early morning 52″ –
10″ Jake

The Krave was kind of left out in the cold this year a bit. That was until Brady put on a clinic with them in a single day. Big Fish Brady hung up a converted TD of 7 with 2 different Jailbait patterns and 1 squirrelly jailbait (which was barbless) in one day alone.

I have to say that I neglect the 9” Grandma badly. I know for certain this is one of the best baits in a couple of boats that catch more fish than I do based on daily averages. I’m not sure why I do this, but I expect it will continue. Do not hesitate to weld on a 9” Grandma and keep it in the water. You WILL catch fish if you put it in front of muskies.

I was very bummed that we couldn’t get a cool bait chomped this year. The P-Crank had one helluva wobble and we maybe didn’t get it enough rod time after we struggled a bit to start the Epic November run. Once fish starting eating, of course we were hesitant to get away from what was working. Next year, we will get some teeth marks on some P-Cranks!! Remember you heard it here when next fall’s report comes out.

Rod Position Related to Structure
Outside Rod: 33
Inside Rod: 37
Middle Rod: 20

Middle rod action was down a bit again this year. Especially later in the season for Deano again. He even opted out of the middle on the final day of the season, only to have Big Fish Brady pick up a couple quick ones over the middle and lose one, before Captain’s prerogative restored the usual line-up later in the final day. Deano ended the season with his 51” and a 43.5” over the middle.   The 52” hit the inside rod on a shoreline. The biggies played out like this:

Inside: 1 (52”)
Middle: 4 (49.5”, 50-1/8”, 48.5”, 51”)
Outside: 5 (51.5”, 48.25”, 51.75”, 51-3/8”, 48.5”

Depth/Structure
Nothing really new here for me. I’m still bombing along shorelines in that 8-10 foot range most of the time. Even without baitfish present, or maybe especially without baitfish present, it seems important to be close enough to shore to hit stuff that comes out from points and underwater tips, fingers, spines, etc. It seems that some fish will always relate to those structures. We are still catching a lot of fish on the edge of waypoints marked for me on GPS to aim for when moving along a shoreline. These waypoints typically mark a shallow spot that can be anywhere from 3 to 5 feet. We got several of the nice fish nearly right on waypoints this year. We did spend some time roaming open water over bait, but didn’t produce a single strike for the effort.

Waypoint that produced a low 40 inch fish
Waypoint that produced a low 40 inch fish

When baitfish is present, we did a lot more of the multiple passes again this year. This continued to be successful and should certainly be a part of your trolling routine, at least in waters similar to what we are fishing here on Lake of the Woods. I firmly believe baits may not get noticed with one or two passes if you are pulling through a lot of bait so keep working a spot if the bait is there. The fish will find your lure eventually.

Highlights
WOW!!! Where to start with highlights? The obvious one for me is “The Double.” Being able to direct traffic while my two fishing partners fought muskies. The loudest moment of the fall was definitely the moment I slide the new Drifter XXL Predator net under Deano’s 44 and had 82 inches of muskie in the bottom of the bag together. I have had several muskie/pike doubles and a few pike/pike doubles, but only one other chance at muskie double back in 2007 or so. We did not land both fish that time and it has been a bucket list item or sorts for me ever since. Being net-boy was exactly the way I would have wanted it too so it turned out just perfect. We had talked about it a little bit with all the action we had been having for a couple days and we had a plan, which we were able to execute when it happened. The video turned out awesome with vantage points from J-Man Cam and Bow Cam and Net Cam. I’m looking forward to sharing that with everyone on a Video Monday very early in the New Year!

44" & 38"
44″ & 38″

The First Gibson Family 50! The Gibsons are long-time members of the Mylie’s Place Resort family and have registered 466 released muskies with the Muskies Inc Lunge Log between Mitch, his Mom & Dad (Glen & Rose), sister Regi and son Max. Daughter Maggie has some fish as well.   They had been snake bit on getting to that 50” mark all these years so it was an absolute THRILL to be on the net for what turned out to be a 51.75” fish that hit a 12” Headlock.   Mitch had pumped up 5 fish in a row (43” being the biggest) that day on 10” jakes. I finally bagged one on a Kingpinz that went 46”. Mitch declared he was going to finish out the day with a Headlock and then shortly after that put his rod in the holder for the first time all day so he could repair my Kingpinz. When he put the rod in the holder, I suggested he go ahead and change it to the Headlock right then since the action of a Headlock really doesn’t require much pumping. Less than 5 minutes after he set the rod back in the holder (and while still working on my bait), the big girl strikes and the fight is on! Video of that sequence is awesome as well. Sorry for tossing your chopper over the side of the boat, Mitch!! It did hit the gunnel first, but it never really had a chance to hold on. We didn’t realize where it ended up and that I was the culprit until video review later that night. We had a helluva laugh watching that one from multiple angles. Always bring a back-up sets of gloves/mitts when you fish with excitable types! Congratulations Mitch and the Gibson family. The ice is now broken and the biggies will start to come more frequently is my prediction. Great family of great anglers and a memory for me that will always rank right up there near the very top of the heap.

Mitch's 51.75" 12" Headlock
Mitch’s 51.75″
12″ Headlock

Tom’s personal best!!! Another long-time friend and resort family member that had been held short of the 50 mark. Tom had a 49 inch class fish or two on the board and a 49.5” for his boat that he netted, but the 50 inchers have either fallen off or not eaten. This one was super exciting, because it was much too close to call in the net. I had landed a 49.5” about 30 minutes prior and this one wasn’t quite as hefty so we sure didn’t call it 50 before it was on the board with the tail pinched. It was a no doubter on the board, getting a full 1/8” passed the 50” mark for his personal best!   We will celebrate that fish properly during my visit to Green Bay for Monday Night Football on December 8. Way to go, Tom!! RSCN2007 A new record for the Pooh boat! We had what would almost have to be considered the perfect day. The Dirty Dozen. 12 strikes. 12 fish landed. All muskies. No pike. Good size with most in the 40s, only a couple under 40 and the biggest a 48.5” hawg that ate Matlock to end the day. An interesting side-note was the record breaker, (fish #11) was caught by me on a Kingpinz Perch pattern. This bait was lost an hour after it caught its first fish the first day I used it. It was a situation where the line was caught in a crevice and snapped quickly before we could back up past it and try to pull it free. When this happens, you sometimes get the bait back, but after a couple more passes on the shoreline, we did not see it that day. A good week later, I was chatting with new guests Dave and Cale when they mentioned they found a bait in an area that I like to fish and asked if I had lost one. I said, “as a matter of fact”….it was easy to identify because it was not a common bait so we went down to the boat for a look-see. The guys happily donated my bait back to me and it was the bait that broke the previously daily record of 10 that afternoon. How cool is that? Cale and Dave have some super sweet karma coming their way for sure! I offered them a bait as a reward, but they refused. Great guys! That Perch Kingpinz went on to catch a couple more fish as well. I’m just plain lucky to have it in more ways than one!

Fish #11 on the Day of the Dirty Dozen.  The old record falls to a 43" on a Perch Kingpinz
Fish #11 on the Day of the Dirty Dozen. The old record falls to a 43″ on a Perch Kingpinz

The Day of the Dozen started a 3 day run that will be tough to duplicate. After going 12-12, we went 9-12 the following day and 11-12 the day after that. Those are days I’ve only heard of from some of the best anglers I’ve gotten to know during my time at the resort. It was in incredible run of reasonably stable weather and winds that didn’t force us away from the areas that were giving up fish. The 4th day of that week gave us an awful wind direction and velocity that made it unsafe to travel to, and fish, those areas and we came back to reality with a 1-5 day.

No skunks!! YESSSSS….for the first fall ever, I managed to get through the entire run without a skunk. We ended up with 5 days that were saved only by 1 single solitary muskie, but we caught at least 1 fish of the right flavour every single time out. One more thing I can scratch off the bucket list!

The Double Habanero Day!! A new tradition was started when we (ok, when I decided) that the package of Habanero beef sticks that Deano brought with would be opened up with any fish 4 feet or longer. Perhaps I should have raised the bar a little because when you have a label that saves “Not for Children” and the name they give to them is “Fire in the Hole”, eating a couple of them in a day is not the best for anyone with a sensitive stomach. The day before the Dirty Dozen, we landed 5 muskies…the first of which was my 52” first thing in the morning. So, we all had a Habanero stick about 7:45 after we got the fish released and baits back in the water. Later that day a little before 4, Big Fish Brady bagged his PB of 51-3/8” so we went into the cooler for Habanero sticks again. Yikes…wasn’t sure my stomach was going to survive the day before the pending daily moonset or moonrise that was set for near 3 pm. I was thinking a pitstop on shore was going to be needed, but managed to talk my system out of that and then it was rewarded with a second dose of “Fire in the Hole.” Well, we adjusted the rules a bit because we would have ended up out of Habaneros before the week was over this year and have since adjusted them for next year. Deano may need 2-3 packs just in case we hit the jackpot again. Let me just say, nobody is looking forward to celebrating a personal best during Epic November 2015. Any personal best for the Team Epic is a two sticker for the crew mates and a 3 sticker for the lucky angler. With PBs of 54” on weight and 54.5” on length for Deano, 53” for J-Man and 51-3/8” for Big Fish Brady, it will take a dandy that is worthy of breathing fire! Here’s to more Habanero fish during Epic November 2015. The bar still starts at 4 feet! None of this would have come about without former Team Epic member John Kennedy, who started the hot stick tradtion with a stick called the “Hawg’s Ass” that came from his local meat shop in IL back when he lived there. Watching Deano and Johnny eat those things was some of the best comedy of the fall those two years. We recorded most of our Habanero celebrations this fall. We might have to sneak some into the Video Monday highlights. Anyone want to see grown men cry?

Fire in the Hole!
Fire in the Hole!

Season bests for the Rabbi and J-Man. Spending time in the boat with exceptionally knowledgeable and accomplished anglers is always a treat. This year, I had 3 days with both the Godfather and the Rabbi. I was also able to help keep the Rabbi’s ridiculous streak of years with a 30 pound class fish going when he landed the 51.75” tank in October. Good times and memories for me. I firmly believe I lost the biggest fish of the year I had on in August, but that 52” the boys let me land in November was a great way to cap off another season in which I already considered a great success for me personally. It was nice to get in on the big fish action late in the season.

The Rabbi's 51.5"  10" Headlock
The Rabbi’s 51.5″
10″ Headlock

I caught a fish on a Headlock!   Out of 28 Headlock fish last year, I didn’t land a single one of them. This year, I welded on a Headlock the first day out and picked up a 47.5” for the first trolling fish of the year and my first ever on a Supernatural Big Bait. YES!!!

J-Man's 1st Headlock Fish! 47.5" - 12" HL
J-Man’s 1st Headlock Fish!
47.5″ – 12″ HL

The Big Fish Brady Show!! Sometimes we invoke the penalty box rule and spread the wealth around a bit, but often a new guy gets a little more leeway. Deano learned his lesson about calling the penalty box on me last year when he promptly got a sub 30” muskie on my rod for his effort. This year, we were treated to watching Brady reel in 9 fish during an 11 fish day. Deano finally got bit after Brady rattled off 5 in a row, but even then Brady couldn’t let him have the limelight. Burning his bait in after Deano hooked up, Brady got bit and we ended up landing #6 for Brady (38”) before Deano’s 44” completed the Double.

Pike-free streak!!! We went 21 fish in a row without a pike. Starting the afternoon of the Double Habanero Day through the next day with 12 and 6 more the following morning until another pike showed up. Gotta love a pike-free diet!!

I got to net a total of 4 personal bests this fall. With some pretty good anglers in the Pooh Boat, those PBs are getting harder to raise. The memories of being a part of someone’s biggest fish ever will never fade, even when they are replaced by a bigger fish. Also had a couple of best ever days for anglers in my boat, with Mitch’s 6 (including the 51.75”, which was #6) and Big Fish Brady’s aforementioned 9er.

Not So Cool Stuff
I parked Pooh on rocks more times this year than ever before. Must have been 5-6 total. Not one of the landings was soft either! UGH! Had to get the paddles out 3-4 times and had a few moments where I thought I might be crawling over the bow to lift and push to get him back floating. A couple spots that were new and one I hadn’t fished for a long time, but others were just “damnnnnn, I don’t remember that sticking out so far!” moments that add a little more excitement to the day than necessary.

Wind and cold! AGAIN! After a warming trend in mid-October, the water temp held steady and higher than average through to the end of the month. However, when the thermometer started to go south, it went south fast. We ended up with another bone chilling finish to the season on November 8. The bay was frozen solid completely less than a week later as we left for the winter.  That is easily the quickest end to the season I can remember. Water temps were prime for more good action the last day I was on the water, but daytime highs were in the 20s with overnight lows in the teens. Getting back out just wasn’t really possible with the closing-up chores I had left to do.

Split ring failures!! We had split rings fail on a 13” Grandma after a strong strike that felt heavy to Big Fish Brady. All of the sudden, the rod unloads and when he gets the bait back to the boat, we find the rear 7/0 hook and split ring is gone. I sure wish they would make the hook hangers big enough to accommodate triple split rings!!   Then, on a retrieve at the end of a run to prepare to move, Deano is bringing in my bait while I am up front pulling the bow mounted transducer and has a big wide-open mouth chomp the 10” Jake right at the back corner of the boat. Two head shakes and it was all over. We make a couple more passes with the hope there may be another fish in the area, or that this fish is feeding aggressively and might eat again. The rod loads up in the holder again, but this time is a pike. As I reach down with the long needle nose pliers, I notice the middle hook and triple split ring is missing. UGH! Not good for the fish and certainly a bummer for the anglers. Two heavy fish lost to equipment failure. We did inspect all Grandmas before deployment after that, but very hard to fathom a triple split ring failing.

Equipment/Gear
We had multiple GoPros capturing the action this year. I had one mounted at the front of the boat to shoot towards the back and capture some strikes as well as one on the new Drifter XXL Predator net. Thanks to Andrew K for the idea to do a net-cam mount. I found the GoPro roll bar mount to be junk after it showed up damaged and was not at all built to take any beating. It lasted about 5 days. I found a Ram mount that attached to the net handle and that was very well-built. I would highly recommend that mount over the GoPro version. I got to play with a Hero 2 and Hero 3 as well as the Hero 960s I had myself. The higher quality HD with 60 FPS is really nice, but you sure go through batteries and SD cards. Of course, I missed a few good sequences getting used to the new models, but managed to capture most of the action with one camera or another. Hopefully, everyone enjoys Video Mondays this winter! I know I’m looking forward to putting some of the action together for people to see.

Ram mount Net Cam on the Drifter XXL Predator
Ram mount Net Cam on the Drifter XXL Predator

I added another Thorne Bros custom trolling rod to the arsenal. Because you can never have enough gear when you are stuck up in the wilderness! That 8’6” stick, paired with a Shimano Tekota LC, is absolutely the sweetest set-up I can imagine for trolling big cranks. Treat yourself to one of those combos if you spend any time at all trolling for muskies.

The Drifter XXL Predator net is BIG! It was nice to have the long handle and super wide hoop for the Double! Overall, being a Beckman fan, I had a tough time getting used to the weight of both the hoop and the deeper, thicker bag. I really did like attachment on the end of the handle that offered some better leverage when turning the hope one way or another mid-scoop. Overall, the Predator is a well-built piece of gear and any fans of that other brand can be pretty confident this one will meet all your needs!   The smaller mesh squares are much better for the fish than that other brand’s big mesh squares. We had very little blood in the boat from cut fins. Well done, Drifter. I can’t wait to get my hands on the lightweight series that will be similar to my Beckman. I will look for them during show season. 38-44double Other Observations
Another slow start, overall. The warm temps in October seemed to slow down the hot bite at times, but some of our guests catching fish regularly. The Pooh boat was having a tough time putting together back to back good days, despite some real nice fish in the mix early. I was very concerned about the inconsistency of the bite heading into Epic November 2014, but we got some stable weather with the temps coming down into the prime target area and things jumped off pretty good.

Pumping the rods seemed to make a difference this year. I had my crews doing a lot of pumping and many fish were caught while rods were in their hands. During one 7 fish day, Mitch pumped up 5 in a row.  Even when I confiscated his bait after the 4th consecutive fish on it, he picked up number 5 pumping a different bait. He had been both inside and outside to structure with 2 of us in the boat. When you combine the increased efficiency of less snags and being able to quickly pop stuck baits off the rocks, I think pumping is still the way to go as much as possible. I can’t think of many fish that hit and didn’t stay on while someone was holding the rod. Most of the rips and on-gones, were while rods were in holders. Only a few of the fish that fell off during the fight were hooked while rods being held and pumped. I have to try and add this to my data collection next fall to get more feedback on it.

The morning bite was hot often. Several days we had 2-3 fish before 8 and 9 am. Evening bite was disappointing. Not much going as the sun went down and we worked it hard a few times late in the year with the moonset/rise nearly matching up with sunset a few days in a row.

Special Thanks to: Some of these will be repeating year after year so humor me a bit……

Duffy Thury (Supernatural Big Baits) for keeping me in enough Headlocks that I did not hesitate to run them and beat then up from start to finish. If you don’t have a couple, you should. Thank you, Duff!! https://www.facebook.com/supernaturalbigbaits

John Dadson, for putting me in touch with Mike Blewett. Mike makes the Wick Onez line of baits and sent me 2 Kingpinz with a request to “beat the crap out of them.” After I lost one the first day, he quickly painted another and got that to me as well. Great baits that will get heard from more and more in the future. Thank you, Mike! https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100004960186963&fref=ts

Dick Moore (Moore’s Lures) — leaders and hooks. Dick got me set up with the tools to make my own leaders and got me started with a hook supply that turned out to be short. Next year I need to order 200, instead of 150. Even with Deano and Brady bringing some more 5/0s along, we had to ration the last few days. http://www.mooreslures.com

Bob Schmidt: Just Encase tackle boxes. I WILL NOT muskie fish without them! http://justencase.com/

Thorne Bros Custom Rod & Tackle: Proud to be a Thorne Bros Pro Staffer. Nearly all of my gear is available through Thorne! http://www.thornebros.com

Bill Schwartz from Slammer Tackle for letting me beat up a jointed deep running bait. Bagged a nice 43” on it too!

To the Godfather, Rabbi, Brad, Tink, Tom, Mark, Jordan, Mitch, Deano and Big Fish Brady for making the trip to Lake of the Woods and spending time in the Pooh boat. I had great crews all the way through. You get a lot more done on the water when everyone is on the top of their games.

Final Thoughts To be perfectly honest, I was not as excited about the Fall 2014 trolling season as I usually would have been. It had been a long, stressful season with the late spring and resulting problems associated with that to start things off and then the nearly record high water levels that were scary well into August. Couple that with some other things going on and a sinus infection……I was just looking forward to the end of the year. I hoped that would change once we got fishing and finding some fish. The people I fished with made it enjoyable to be on the water, whether we caught fish or not.   I was reminded again that the fish are a bonus. Even during some cold and wind and rain…you can enjoy the time on the water.

Life is good even before you get a bait in the water some days.
Life is good even before you get a bait in the water some days.

As of 2014, the resort will officially be my life’s work. I know where I will be every spring through the fall for many years to come. Now that the offseason is here, I can honestly say I will be looking forward to spring again in a couple of months, but for the time being…a lot of time is needed to rest, get back into my routine of eating better & exercising, and keeping tabs on all of my amazing friends out there.

Please feel free to follow along on Facebook if you’d like to keep track of my adventures this winter. I will be travelling across the lower 48 now that I am no longer a home-owner and need to find alternate places to hang my hat. This was a bit of a dream for me in the past, but something I hoped would be possible once I knew I would be in this business for life. From the bottom of my heart, thank you to all of my guests and friends that make it possible for me to do what I do. I’m blessed to live and work in a beautiful place.

I’m also blessed to be able to unplug and enjoy other things a few months of the year. . Most of all, thank you all for cheering us on as make our way through the resort season and for wishing us well during the offseason. My resort family means the world to me. If not for you all, none of this would be possible.

Watch for Video Mondays coming in the New Year!

Cheers

J-Man 2.0